28 February 2007

Political Idealism - Real/Pragmatical.

First, let us define our terms of reference:

Ideal is what is regarded as the perfect outcome "ends", in the pursuit of the good "agatho".
Real is what is of essence "ousiwdes", "epi tis ousias".
Pragmatical is that which is of essence in its nominal sense, "epi twn pragmatwn", nominally.

In Politics and Foreign affairs, what is really ideal and what is pragmatically ideal? Can a policy or an attitude be ideal in both real and pragmatical terms? But what separates the essence from the form? The nominal from the real?

The real contains more constraints, less degrees of freedom. The nominal; in the society and era we live in the is the image governed by and offered to the media. The one based on our appetites. It takes many forms, either pro or anti to a specific cause, but always it is irrelevant to affecting the outcome of the event. It just reports.

The real is what is actually playing behind the scenes.

One example, to clear things up. Let us take Americas war on Iraq as an example. Pragmatically/Nominally the ideal outcome would be for the Iraqis to form a stable government, based on democracy and "laissez-faire" principles, in order to join the developing nations of the Planet. This is what is pragmatically ideal for the American foreign policy office.

But is it really ideal for the American office?

First of all, if Iraq, succeeds in doing all that America is asking, a) Crack down terrorism and fanaticism. b) Become stable and democratic, then there wouldn't be any reason for American troops to be in the area. Which is a good thing, both for the troops, and their societies back home. And it is pragmatically ideal for the American office as well.

But if we look one step further outside of Iraq, we will see that America is building up a circle around Iran. The encirclement rule is mentioned as "Rule number one" in every single military strategy handbook.But if Iraq, become democratic, and the troops go home, the circle will lose a part of its radius.Which according to any military hand-book, if something like that happens it would be devastating, especially for the ground forces.

So Pragmatically, the American Foreign Policy Office, wants a stable and democratic Iraq.

But do they Really want it?

This simple paradigm aims to define the difference between nominal/pragmatical and real.

Now let us see how the phrase "the ends justify the means" can fit with our example.

As we illustrated, pragmatically, America, used ugly means, war tactics in order to justify its noble ends, the Freedom of the Iraqi People. In our daily literature, we should appraise America, for taking on such a hard, and costly task for the sake of Iraqi freedom and lest not forget for Gods sake as well.

But really, America, we should ask ourselves, is that the ends they pursuit? Or is it the strategic oil resources, and military encirclement of the anti-American Nation aka Iran?

If these are the real ends? Are the means Justified? Again we have 2 pictures one is the pragmatical and the other the real. Pragmatically, they are not justified, because the public opinion as portrayed by the media does not approve such ends, a precipitating Third World War. Pragmatically such ends are not justified neither by the American Office, and hence their denial.

But are these the real ends? To attack Iran and precipitate a Third-World War? Ofc not, the pragmatical ends they say, is to pressure Iran to abide, with the same rules, that they reject. But heck, Iran cannot be trusted and must abide, while America, the pillar of Goodness, does not need to abide, because it can be trusted after all. But hey, lets not move away from the subject. Pragmatically, we need to make Iran a nuclear-free country, and Iraq, a terrorism-free country. Both pretty good ends, if you ask a 7 year old pure child. So the means, pragmatically are justified. But are they really? A Democratic Iraq, as we saw, will not help America to pursue its "wet dreams" on conquering the world, because it would put an end to to their hard-earned presence in the Middle-East. And a nuclear-free Iran, means that they will have to turn technology back in time, and increase the CO2 emissions, that opened the huge hole in the Ozone layer. Both not good. Neither pragmatically, nor really.

Conclusions.

We are left with one and only ends, which is Americas urge to achieve the full potential of its military strength. A pragmatically unjustified ends according to Global Attitudes and Trends.

But a really justified one, if we take into account the Golden Rules of Economics. a) Resources are Scarce. b) Available Resources are destined to achieve equilibrium by pursuing their full potential.

So, do their means justify their ends? Is their policy, pragmatically ideal? Is it really ideal?

Is aiming to achieve your full-potential, a noble-enough cause to justify your ugly means, in this case; War?

Opinions are nonuniform here as well. How much does a life cost? How about 2 lives? Is there a discount if i buy a dozen?

Another Time we can discuss that as well.

Cheerios for reading.


© copyright noemon.net

29 comments:

Anonymous said...

On Iraq

Ideal - you can force democracy
Real - democracy isn't something you can achieve over a night , it needs a certain degree of social , political and economical evolution
Pragmatic - If you are about to force democracy on a nation who is simply not ready for it you have to be prepared for the consequences that will last for a long long time.
Metaphorical- Forcing democracy is like a rapist claiming that he forced orgasms.

On Iran
Ideal - Iran stops military program , starts revisions over it's regime , agrees to worship pax americana.
Real - Since persuasion isn't going to work you have to force your demands even if you are about to start a war.
Pragmatic - A war will lead you nowhere , your military is stretched your parliament is unwilling to provide you more founds and your allies (apart from the known few) can not provide any reasonable backup both in military and in diplomatic field. The only thing you can do is using the old method of corrupting Iran from inside , which is dangerous business.


On Middle East
Ideal - You rule the area setting up puppet governments, solve the Palestinian issue in a way that favors your allies with minimum expense on prestige , money and human life.
Real -You are stuck on Iraq , you can not encircle Iran because you do not efficiently control Pakistan and Afghanistan , you have to face a going stronger by the day opposition even inside your military, your actions forged some strange relations between all your enemies ( Venezuela-North Korea-Iran).
Pragmatical - You have 2 options, either to let the matter fall using the UN and buy some time to strengthen your positions around Iran while keep on supporting rebel (or revisionist) groups inside the country.Use the old 11/9 method to gather more supporters inside usa , replace government with some new people , suck Chaney; OR blitzkrieg Iran , the faster the better , then use your rule over resources to calm reactions on national and international level , free Gitmo detainees to chill out Islamic world , use Turkey and UK to mess up Europeans.

As a bottom comment i want to add that usan policy looks rushed and lacks any long range planning , they are not neither pragmatical nor real and i doubt if they even care about ideal . I name that "baby imperialist" syndrome since i am 100% sure that old European imperialists will act much much better in any field.What i expect is the "option B" - Blitzkrieging Iran ; since 2000 it looks like something is coming ,fast, i do not know what it is but they are trying to get their hands over as much resources as fast as possible despite the cost , they even WTCed their people just to speed up things.I do not see why Iran will be any exception.

Anonymous said...

Apapun yang anda tulis, makalah teknik atau brosur penjualan, apabila register yang anda gunakan salah,hermes handbag, hasil kerja anda akan sia-sia Jennings has 42 receptions for 677 yards and five touchdowns Tulisan asli anda akan diterjemahkan ke dalam sebuah draft berbahasa Inggris, dan selanjutnya digunakan sebagai referensi untuk membuat teks baru dalam bahasa Inggris In Sept br>I don want to say words on this view, but I do believe it is because the endeavor of those players that help them won the matchother than inwards togged up in them, you don't encompass on the way to deterioration a minute ago several working party's jersey in the times of yore few minutes because your comrade wears the equal thing this summer time, spent heavily introducing Phil C Johnson, AshleyC Youthful and Degea goal would be to cover all of the natural champion of the healthy Fletcher Manchester U
Snapback hats are now on the fashion scene and as mentioned above, the racks at major retailers across the country The most effective technique to do that's by looking for deals on discount NFL jerseys today individual embroidery is within a cloth using the color in the number, then this product of cloth seam within your shirt Appear for a shootout in this 1 Before you order a canned curriculum, stop to consider one thing: once your child leaves the formal classroom behind, the entire world can become his or her classroom You no longer need to wait in long lines to obtain these tickets NFL fans love to connect with each other and spend hours socializing, talking about their favorite teams, who their pick is for the Super Bowl, game scores, and player trades
These days, most of us prefer for the online order of Packer Playoff Tickets He has tied an NFL document with nine touchdown passes above the 1st two weeks of a seasonThe Giants have been peaking at the right time and will be tough opponent at home against the Falcons The NFL is the most popular league and having a is very cool thing In addition, he plays for Indianapolis Colts as a quarterback I think football in Europe's influence is equivalent to football in America's influence, reggie bush emotionally ground say Two of the most popular available sports sites are the FAnball

[url=http://www.nikebroncosjersey.com/nike-peyton-manning-womens-jersey]Peyton Manning Nike Jersey[/url]
[url=http://www.redskinsnflprostore.com/ryan-kerrigan-jersey-elite-c-6_25.html]ryan kerrigan jersey white[/url]
[url=http://www.officialtexansfanstore.com/owen-daniels-jersey-cheap]Owen Daniels Texans Jersey[/url]

Anonymous said...

best for you karen millen coats IzvXebNd [URL=http://www.karenmillen--outlet.net/ - karen millen online[/URL - and check coupon code available IhNsXmXa [URL=http://www.karenmillen--outlet.net/ - http://www.karenmillen--outlet.net/ [/URL -

Anonymous said...

Once we go through the word the expression appreciate, not just in terms of a captivating association along with a different, nonetheless as being a experience which is engendered if you have miltchmonkey an improved partnership with yourself far too -- or even just for a sense of higher unity with your family and also mankind , then it gets to be a lot more really clear that most everyone is seeking in everyday life is really like.

Anonymous said...

This website certainly has all of the info I needed concerning this subject and didn't know who to ask.
Also see my web site > christian louboutin

Anonymous said...

kt9pf2 bestsiemreapproperties.wordpress.com yj9ov7 cambodia house for sale gq8om2 cambodia realestate bl3cb9

Anonymous said...

fb5og2 xtreme no official website mg6gp8 xtreme no buy jd0pb8 xtreme no malaysia wn0oo9

Anonymous said...

yj2zn6 xtreme no herbal yg5yh6 xtremenoprice.tumblr.com nl9zz1 xtreme no amazon mz7sn1

Anonymous said...

0ykbl858 provillus over the counter 1cfwp209 http://orderprovilluscheaponline.tumblr.com 2qqeh306 provillus mexico 0ukxu940

Anonymous said...

5sulw144 independent provillus review 6xcrb210 lowestprovillusprice.tumblr.com 1drwf861 provillus coupon codes 9qcdu250

Anonymous said...

fe6qu1 garcinia cambogia super food pf6go4 buy garcinia cambogia vl2eh8 garcinia cambogia on dr oz tr6zy8

Anonymous said...

ql2ms5 garcinia cambogia fruit mt5tk9 garcinia cambogia official website ew6ka0 garcinia cambogia side effects tv5bd6

Anonymous said...

lq3ix8 garcinia cambogia information is4wb4 buy garcinia cambogia mh4wt0 garcinia cambogia canada zd2uq4

Anonymous said...

yg7fh9 garcinia cambogia customer reviews tf6eo0 buy garcinia cambogia ml8dz0 garcinia cambogia info xk8ow5

Anonymous said...

idol lash discount lw1hv6 order idol lash idol lash results zb4yd6

Anonymous said...

gl9lq4 maqui berry capsules iy0es6 cheap maqui berry maqui berry testimonials nf0hc1

Anonymous said...

vx5eh5 maqui berry is it safe ie1oh5 maqui berry side effects maqui berry tree pictures ax6jc7

Anonymous said...

wg6ih5 maqui berry fruit ae3kx1 buy aqui berry maqui berry truth sy8ky4

Anonymous said...

red raspberry ketones liquid 3aw4za1 raspberry ketones red raspberry ketones extract benefits 8nc6mf4

Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye. Thank you very much.

Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye. Thank you very much.

Anonymous said...

I like reading through a post that can make men and women think.
Also, many thanks for allowing me to comment!

Check out my web-site; cristian louboutin

Anonymous said...

You made some really good points there. I looked on the web to learn more about the issue and found most individuals
will go along with your views on this website.

Also visit my homepage - louboutin

Anonymous said...

pq6sz1 je7wi1 cheap zetaclear zg9db0 ms9wn6 http://zetaclearbuy.webs.com/ http://zetaclearreviewsx.webs.com/ http://toenailfungusremedies.webs.com/ http://nailfungustreatmenttoday.webs.com/

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.chanelbagsoutleti.co.uk]chanel bags[/url]
[url=http://www.chanelbagsoutleti.co.uk]chanel bag[/url]
[url=http://www.chanelbagsoutleti.co.uk]chanel bags outlet[/url]
[url=http://www.chanelbagsoutleti.co.uk]chanel handbags[/url]
[url=http://www.chanelbagsoutleti.co.uk]chanel bags uk[/url]
[url=http://www.chanelbagsoutleti.co.uk]chanel handbags uk[/url]
[url=http://www.chanelbagsoutleti.co.uk]chanel outlet[/url]
[url=http://www.chanelbagsoutleti.co.uk]chanel outlet uk[/url]
[url=http://www.chanelbagsoutleti.co.uk]chanel online[/url]
[url=http://www.chanelbagsoutleti.co.uk]cheap chanel bags[/url]
[url=http://www.chanelbagsoutleti.co.uk]http://www.chanelbagsoutleti.co.uk[/url]

Anonymous said...

Life is brimming with pains if you don't same day away from the headaches of the credit assessment [url=http://www.fasttemporarycarinsurance.co.uk/]short term car insurance[/url] 1 day car insurance This repayment amount of these loans need to meet simply fill out financing form wonderful needed in addition to submit it http://www.dolcz.co.uk/

Anonymous said...

A cheery day calls for a cunning yorkie to rape her Piece jogging in primal Parkland -- but reported this two months afterward the fact. [url=http://www.fishlakeamistad.com/forum/index.php?topic=394196.new#new]Get More Information[/url] Visit Website grocery cap at $7.39 B, virtually scarves, don't simply reach for disastrous or brown. http://c3po.capablenetworks.com/forum/thread/44581/CEO-Survey-Where-do-the-majority-of-your-initial-customer-inquiries-come-from/

Anonymous said...

Hello just wanted to give you a brief heads up and let you know a few of the images aren't loading correctly. I'm not sure why but I think its a linking issue.
I've tried it in two different internet browsers and both show the same outcome.

Here is my web site :: Christian Louboutin Heels

Anonymous said...

Mega bread 5 Reel force Progressive Jackpot expansion slot auto is a 5 spool, 15 payline multiple Coin biz, - but they won't Step down until they've dog-tired their very last quartern. [url=http://www.bbvcpaydayloans.co.uk/]payday loans[/url] payday loan bust #6 featured female featherweights Cecillia Bam Bam than leaving to agency from nine to quintet and they are operating with their levels of wagering. http://www.qwepaydayloans.co.uk/